So, why would a nice Protestant girl consider Orthodoxy?
In the late 90's/early 2000's, I served as worship leader in several churches: non-denominational, Methodist and Southern Baptist. There was a need, I was available. I learned much during these times and felt honored to be of service to the Lord. But I had some nagging doubts and a few things just weren't adding up for me.
- The Presence of God: I would hear remarks such as, "The presence of the Lord was strong today," or "worship was really good" and other words to that effect. Was it "good", did the Lord "show up," or did we play someone's favorite music that fills the worshipper with warm fuzzies? Surely we can believe Jesus when he said, "wherever two or more are gathered in my name, there I am."
- Worship Music: Was it me, or were songs starting to sound alike, especially those recorded by certain worship ministries that shall remain nameless? Songs were predictable, shallow and anthropocentric. Isn't worship all about God? Where was the Trinity and why is it not mentioned? Songs were about Jesus or the Holy Spirit, but is the Trinity divided? And what about the 'Jesus-is-my-boyfriend' songs?
- Worship Wars: We were caught in a few of those in the churches we served. Pastors wanted one style, congregation wanted another. Pastors' attitudes basically came down to this: "If they don't like it, they can leave." Wow! How was that shepherding the flock, seeking the good of others, loving them with the love of Christ?
- Pride: Rampant. One pastor once commented that the worship leader is only as good as the last service he\she led. Is this how we are to pursue ministry? What evil passions within the sinful human nature does that mindset conjure?
- And my very favorite ... GOD TOLD ME! I love this one! God seemed to be telling different people different things and they didn't always mesh. Schizophrenia is not one of God's attributes.
These are just a few of the issues I had. I sometimes came away from a service thinking there must be something wrong with me since I don't feel the way others proclaim to feel. But, I didn't want to rock the boat of anyone - not the pastors, other team members, or even my family. I just quietly began studying church history on my own and found the further back in history I went, the stronger the conviction became that my doubts weren't necessarily off-base. The reformation era looked good, unlike what I was experiencing, so I decided to hang out in the 16th century for a while.
Stay tuned for Part II.